Lynchburg Divorce Lawyers

Open NavigationOpen Search
  • Home
  • Contact
    • Location Map
  • About
    • Attorneys
    • Awards and Recognition
    • Do I need a divorce lawyer?
  • Virginia Divorce Basics
    • Uncontested Divorce
    • Equitable Distribution
    • Spousal Support
    • Child Custody and Visitation
    • Child Support
  • Additional Resources
    • Divorce and Family Law Articles
    • Divorce and Family Law Legal Forms

Spousal support and “manifest injustice” exception: newsworthy divorce appeals

July 10, 2015 by Brian Moore Leave a Comment

The Decision:

In Giraldi v. Giraldi the Virginia Court of Appeals reversed a reservation of spousal support awarded to an adulterous spouse. The decision rested primarily upon the absence of facts sufficient to prove “manifest injustice” by “clear and convincing evidence”.

The Law:

The decision whether to award spousal support is usually left to the discretion of the trial court. An appellate court will not reverse a spousal support determination so long as the trial court considers all of the relevant facts and does not abuse its discretion. In other words, a trial court’s spousal support decision must be plainly wrong or without any supporting evidence if it is to be overturned on appeal. Needless to say, reversal of a trial court’s spousal support ruling is an exceedingly rare occurrence.

Divorce lawyers who keep up with these things sat up and took notice when this published opinion was recently issued.

Current law (Virginia Code 20-107.1(B)) states:

“no permanent maintenance and support shall be awarded from a spouse if there exists in such spouse’s favor a ground of divorce under the provisions of subdivision (1) of § 20-91. However, the court may make such an award notwithstanding the existence of such ground if the court determines from clear and convincing evidence, that a denial of support and maintenance would constitute a manifest injustice, based upon the respective degrees of fault during the marriage and the relative economic circumstances of the parties.”

Adultery is a fault ground for divorce. Thus, when a spouse if found guilty of adultery, he or she is barred from receiving spousal support in the absence of clear and convincing evidence that the bar would constitute a “manifest injustice”.

The Facts:

So what were the pertinent facts in the case? The parties were married just over a decade. The wife admitted to committing adultery over a 6 or so month period prior to the divorce proceedings being brought by the Husband. The evidence established that the relationship was already on the rocks but that the wife was guilty of reprehensible behavior in addition to adultery. The court’s examples included her threat to turn the Husband into the police after slamming her own hand in the door several times. For his part, the Husband was accused by the Wife of being unavailable and emotionally non-supportive. Both spouses were employed but husband earned substantially more income than the wife.

The Reasoning:

The Appeals Court noted its prior opinions holding that a higher level of justification is required for the “manifest injustice” exception to be “based upon” the respective degrees of fault. In addition, “respective degrees of fault” include any acts or conditions which contributed to the marriage’s failure and not just those relied upon as legal grounds for divorce.

So what was the Appeals Court’s ultimate reasoning in this case?

First, there was no indication in the record that the trial court determined that the wife proved by clear and convincing evidence that a support bar would constitute “manifest injustice”. That’s it. The trial court transcript did not give any indication that the proper standard of proof was considered.

Second, there was no indication that trial court considered the two factors upon which the manifest injustice must be based: 1) respective fault during the marriage, and 2) the relative economic circumstances of the parties. Without any factual findings regarding these factors it was impossible to then conclude that the wife’s evidence established a “manifest injustice” would occur if she were to be barred from receiving spousal support.

Third, and most importantly, the Appeals Court stated “a “manifest injustice” cannot be speculative”. It must be shown to presently exist by clear and convincing evidence. The evidence in this case, according to the Appeals panel, was incapable of meeting such a burden and the trial court’s statement, that the future for the parties was uncertain, was not enough to carry the day for the wife.

Conclusion:

We will wait to see how this opinion affects practice and strategy in the trial courts. It most certainly will keep divorce lawyers and judges on their toes in adultery cases where a bar to spousal support is being sought and the “manifest injustice” exception is being argued.

Learn more about spousal support in general on our spousal support page. 

If you have any questions about spousal support or are facing a divorce, please contact The Moore Law Firm PLLC to arrange a consultation.

Filed Under: Spousal Support Tagged: divorce appeal, manifest injustice

Back to top ▴

About Brian Moore

Virginia family and divorce attorney devoted to guiding and protecting families faced with divorce and family law matters. Brian enjoys staying abreast of cutting edge technology, science, and psychology as it relates to the practice of law and leveraging what he learns to deliver value and results to his clients.

Contact The Moore Law PLLC

The Moore Law Firm PLLC
3311 Old Forest Rd, #105
Lynchburg 24501
Phone: (434) 299-0130
Fax: (434) 299-0130

Recent Posts

  • Basic evidence in a child custody case
  • Protecting your children during divorce
  • Spousal support and “manifest injustice” exception: newsworthy divorce appeals
  • How to establish paternity in Virginia
  • Lawyers need to listen more and talk less

Categories

  • Child Custody and Visitation
  • Child Support
  • Divorce Consultation
  • Spousal Support
  • Virginia Divorce Articles

Archives

  • August 2017
  • July 2015
  • May 2015
  • April 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014

Disclaimer:

This website is not intended to constitute legal advice and does not constitute legal advice. By posting and/or maintaining this website and its contents, The Moore Law Firm PLLC does not intend to solicit legal representation business from clients for matters where Virginia law does not apply. Some links within this website may lead to other sites. The Moore Law Firm PLLC does not necessarily sponsor, endorse, or otherwise approve of the materials appearing in such sites. Contacts via email or online submissions do not create a confidential relationship and do not create an attorney-client relationship.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The Moore Law Firm PLLC

3311 Old Forest Rd, #105
Lynchburg, Virginia 24501
United States (US)
Phone: (434) 299-0130
Fax: (434) 299-0130
Top 100 Family Law Attorney in Virginia recognition of Brian R. Moore

Avvo Top-Rated Divorce Lawyer

Brian Moore Divorce Attorney
Divorce Lawyers near me
American Society of Legal Advocates Top 40 under 40 Family Law

Contact us online:

[si-contact-form form=’4′]

Article Categories:

  • Child Custody and Visitation
  • Child Support
  • Divorce Consultation
  • Spousal Support
  • Virginia Divorce Articles

Follow Us!

Disclaimer:

This website is not intended to constitute legal advice and does not constitute legal advice. By posting and/or maintaining this website and its contents, The Moore Law Firm PLLC does not intend to solicit legal representation business from clients for matters where Virginia law does not apply. Some links within this website may lead to other sites. The Moore Law Firm PLLC does not necessarily sponsor, endorse, or otherwise approve of the materials appearing in such sites. Contacts via email or online submissions do not create a confidential relationship and do not create an attorney-client relationship.

Divorce & Family Law Attorney Distinctions and Awards:

Divorce and Family Lawyer Award Badges

Set up a divorce consultation:

The Moore Law Firm PLLC
3311 Old Forest Rd, #105
Lynchburg, Virginia 24501
Phone: (434) 299-0130
Fax: (434) 299-0130

Normal Business Hours:

Monday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sunday9:00 AM - 5:00 PM

Weekends and after hours appointments available on a limited basis.

Copyright © 2023 ·The Moore Law Firm PLLC